Last Updated: April 2026
TL;DR:
- Diamonds form 90 miles underground at up to 2,000°F, but they didn’t become “precious” until marketing caught up with geology — that took roughly 2,300 years.
- The 1871 discovery of an 83.50-carat diamond at Colesberg Kopje flooded the market so badly that diamonds lost 50% of their value by 1919.
- Only 10% of American brides got diamond engagement rings in 1939. By 1990, that number hit 80% — not because diamonds got rarer, but because one ad agency rewrote what “forever” meant.
Diamonds are the hardest natural material on Earth, but hardness never made them valuable. For most of human history, rubies and emeralds outranked them on every royal finger that mattered. If you’re asking when did diamonds become valuable, the honest answer involves less geology and more advertising than most people expect — and diamonds aren’t nearly as rare as the price tag suggests. Here’s the actual timeline, mine discovery by mine discovery, campaign by campaign.
[[IMAGE_1]]
How Old Are Diamonds, Really?
Diamonds are roughly 900 million to 3.5 billion years old, formed long before humans existed. The oldest known diamond deposits date back about 900 million years. Humans didn’t start mining them until around the 4th century BC in India — meaning diamonds sat underground for hundreds of millions of years before anyone valued them at all.
According to the GIA, the earliest diamond trading happened along Indian river networks that fed into the Silk Road, moving stones toward China and eventually Europe. I’ve cut and set thousands of stones in my career, and the irony never gets old: the gem takes a billion years to form and about 70 years of ad campaigns to become “priceless.”
[[IMAGE_2]]
Diamonds Form 90 Miles Beneath Your Feet
Diamonds crystallize about 90 miles (145 km) down in the earth’s mantle, where temperatures hit 2,000°F (1,093°C) and pressure runs around 725,000 pounds per square inch. That’s roughly 50 times the pressure at the bottom of the ocean. Volcanic eruptions — specifically kimberlite pipes — blast the crystals up toward the surface fast enough that they don’t turn back into graphite along the way.
Without that violent elevator ride, there’d be no diamond industry. The stones would stay locked 90 miles down forever, which is a funnier kind of “forever” than the one in De Beers’ slogan.
[[IMAGE_3]]
Where Were Diamonds First Discovered?
India was the world’s only known diamond source from roughly 4th century BC until 1725, when Brazil produced the first credible alternative. For nearly 2,000 years, every diamond in circulation — in Rome, in the Ottoman court, in medieval Europe — traced back to Indian riverbeds along the Krishna, Godavari, and Penner rivers.
That single-source monopoly is the first clue to why diamonds eventually got so expensive: scarcity of supply routes, not scarcity of the mineral itself. Diamond and coal are both pure carbon; the difference is depth and pressure, not rarity of the element.
[[IMAGE_4]]
What Ancient Cultures Believed About Diamonds
Early Indian and Roman owners didn’t wear diamonds as ring centerpieces — they wore them as talismans, engraving tools, and battle charms. Warriors carried uncut diamonds believing the stones offered protection. During the Dark Ages, some physicians prescribed ingesting powdered diamond to cure illness, which tells you more about medieval medicine than about the gem.
Diamond’s real, verifiable property back then was its hardness — a 10 on the Mohs scale, still unmatched by any natural material today. That made it useful for engraving metal centuries before anyone thought to put one on a ring.
[[IMAGE_5]]
Why Did the Kimberley Mine Discovery Crash Diamond Prices?
In 1871, an 83.50-carat diamond turned up at Colesberg Kopje in South Africa, triggering a prospecting rush that opened the Kimberley Mine — the first large-scale diamond mine in history. Supply exploded, and by 1919 diamonds had lost roughly 50% of their market value because there simply weren’t enough buyers for the flood of new stones.
Five years earlier, in 1866, a 15-year-old named Erasmus Jacobs found a 21.25-carat diamond on the banks of the Orange River, thinking it was a pretty pebble. That single find kicked off the entire South African diamond rush. Within a decade, the “rare gem” had become common enough that upper-class buyers turned back to rubies, emeralds, and sapphires for engagement pieces.
[[IMAGE_6]]
When Colored Gemstones Outranked Diamonds
Between roughly 1870 and 1900, colored stones were the status symbol of choice among elites, precisely because diamonds had become too available to signal wealth. This is the part of diamond history most marketing retrospectives skip: diamonds spent decades as the discount option before they became the “traditional” one.
That changed in 1888, when Cecil John Rhodes consolidated diamond mines into De Beers Consolidated Mines Ltd, giving one company effective control over global supply. Controlling supply is step one of controlling price. It took De Beers another 60 years to solve step two: demand.
[[IMAGE_7]]
Why Did Only 10% of Brides Get Diamond Rings in 1939?
Diamond engagement rings existed since at least 1477 among royalty, but they weren’t standard for ordinary couples until well into the 20th century. In 1939, only about 10% of first-time American brides received a diamond engagement ring — most got no ring, a colored stone, or a family heirloom instead.
The engagement ring tradition itself is older than the diamond-ring tradition. Pope Innocent III mandated a betrothal waiting period back in 1215, formalizing the ring as a commitment symbol across the Roman Catholic world. But diamonds only became the default engagement stone generations later, after a marketing campaign did what centuries of tradition hadn’t.
[[IMAGE_8]]
Mary of Burgundy’s 1477 Proposal
The earliest well-documented diamond engagement ring dates to 1477, when Austria’s Archduke Maximilian proposed to Mary of Burgundy with a diamond ring. According to the American Gem Society, this proposal is widely cited as the moment diamond rings entered European royal courts as a symbol of commitment — five centuries before the average couple could afford one.
For those 500 years, diamond rings stayed a royalty-and-elite privilege. The stone was too scarce, and the supply chain too fragile, for mass adoption. That gap between “royal tradition” and “everyone’s tradition” is exactly what De Beers set out to close in the 1930s and 40s.
[[IMAGE_9]]
What Was De Beers’ “A Diamond Is Forever” Campaign?
In 1947, De Beers’ ad agency N.W. Ayer & Sons had copywriter Frances Gerety pen the line “A Diamond Is Forever.” The campaign linked diamonds permanently to eternal love and marriage, and within a few years it reversed decades of falling demand — pushing diamond engagement ring adoption from 10% of US brides in 1939 toward 80% by 1990.
De Beers didn’t invent scarcity marketing from nothing — the company that coined the slogan had spent nearly two decades testing which emotional hooks moved product before Gerety’s line stuck. This wasn’t a lucky tagline. It was the payoff of a sustained, deliberate strategy to make an oversupplied commodity feel irreplaceable, and the engagement ring specifically became the vehicle for that strategy.
[[IMAGE_10]]
The “Two Months’ Salary” Ad That Sold America on Diamonds
A 1977 De Beers ad, shot in black and white on what looked like the Cape Cod coast, showed a man proposing after saving two months’ salary. The tagline: “How else would two months’ salary last forever?” It did two things at once — it put a socially acceptable price floor on the ring, and it told men exactly how much to spend without ever stating a dollar figure.
According to National Geographic, that pricing benchmark — later stretched to “two to three months’ salary” — became one of the most successful embedded-price campaigns in advertising history, still quoted by jewelry salespeople today even though it has zero basis in gemology. De Beers’ actual diamond sourcing had nothing to do with the number; the figure was pure behavioral marketing.
[[IMAGE_11]]
What Can Marketers Still Learn From De Beers Today?
The core lesson: controlling supply sets the floor price, but controlling the emotional story sets the ceiling price. De Beers held the diamond supply chain for decades without much demand growth until it manufactured an emotional narrative — love, permanence, masculinity — that made buyers self-select a spending amount without ever being told to.
By 2011, antitrust pressure and new entrants like Alrosa had eroded De Beers’ hold on the market, though the company still moves a significant share of global rough diamond supply. Whether De Beers still holds a monopoly is a fair question worth its own answer, but the marketing playbook it wrote in 1947 outlived the monopoly itself.
[[IMAGE_12]]
Diamonds and Coal Share a Birth Certificate
Both are pure carbon. The only difference is where the carbon sat and how much pressure it took. Coal forms near the surface under modest heat; diamond forms 90 to 240 miles down under conditions coal never sees. According to the Natural Diamonds Council, this shared origin is why lab-grown diamonds — which replicate that pressure artificially — are chemically identical to mined stones, carbon atom for carbon atom.
I bring this up because customers still ask me if a diamond is “worth more” for being naturally formed. Structurally, no. The 900-million-year wait doesn’t add hardness or brilliance. It adds a story, and stories are what sell rings.
[[IMAGE_13]]
The Bottom Line
Diamonds didn’t become valuable because they’re rare — the 1871 Kimberley discovery proved they aren’t, and the 50% price crash by 1919 proved the market knew it. Diamonds became valuable because one company spent 20 years building a story that made “forever” synonymous with a carbon crystal. If you’re buying a diamond today, buy it for the cut, clarity, and craftsmanship, not because a 1947 ad slogan told your grandfather what love was supposed to cost. Know the history, and you’ll negotiate the price with a clearer head.
[[IMAGE_14]]
Frequently Asked Questions
When did diamonds first become valuable?
Diamonds were valued for hardness and engraving use as early as the 4th century BC in India, but they weren’t treated as the premier gemstone for engagement rings until after De Beers’ 1947 “A Diamond Is Forever” campaign. Before that, rubies, emeralds, and sapphires often outranked diamonds among the wealthy.
Why were diamonds not popular before the 1900s?
Diamonds were considered too available after the 1871 Kimberley Mine discovery flooded the market, causing a 50% price drop by 1919. Colored gemstones became the preferred choice for the elite because diamonds no longer signaled exclusivity.
Who made diamonds popular for engagement rings?
De Beers Consolidated Mines, through its 1947 “A Diamond Is Forever” campaign written by Frances Gerety at N.W. Ayer & Sons, is credited with making diamonds the default engagement ring stone in the United States and, later, globally.
Did the price of diamonds ever crash?
Yes. After the 1871 discovery at Colesberg Kopje and the opening of the Kimberley Mine, diamond supply surged so fast that prices dropped by roughly 50% by 1919. That crash is part of why De Beers pursued supply consolidation and then demand-side marketing.
Are diamonds actually rare?
Not particularly, especially compared to the marketing around them. Diamonds are common enough in the earth’s mantle that a single 1866 riverbank find in South Africa triggered a mining rush within a few years. Their high price reflects controlled supply and demand engineering more than true geological scarcity.
How old is the oldest known diamond?
The youngest diamond deposits are estimated at around 900 million years old, while some diamonds are believed to be over 3 billion years old — far older than complex life on Earth.

Tiger is a fashion&jewelry lover. He is also a fashion jewelry manufacturer that help thousands of small business to grow and also do business with some big fashion jewelry brands. He is a truly metal expert and he will share some information you are looking for.
