What To Do With Old Pins And Brooches?(10 Ideas You can Get Inspiration)

Hey! I finally find the Answer!

Last Updated: April 2026

TL;DR:

  • Check for a maker’s mark first — signed pieces from Trifari, Coro, Weiss, or Eisenberg can sell for $50-$500+, far more than any craft project is worth.
  • The fastest repurposing trick: strip the pin-back with needle-nose pliers and glue or solder on a bail — that turns any brooch into a pendant necklace in under 10 minutes.
  • No soldering required: a flat-back magnet and E6000 jewelry glue turns a broken-pin brooch into a fridge magnet that will outlast the original clasp.

Every jewelry box has one — that stiff, dated brooch from a grandmother or a thrift store find that hasn’t left the drawer in a decade. Before you toss it, know this: pin-back jewelry is one of the easiest categories to convert into something you’ll actually wear, because the flat surface and sturdy clasp mechanism give you more to work with than a ring or a pair of earrings. If you’ve already sorted through what to do with old necklaces, this is the next drawer to tackle. Below are ways to turn old pins and brooches into pieces you’ll keep.

make a bracelet

Should You Sell That Old Brooch Before You Repurpose It?

Check the back for a maker’s mark before you touch a pair of pliers. Signed pieces from Trifari, Coro, Weiss, Eisenberg, or Schiaparelli routinely sell for $50 to $500+ on the resale market, and cutting one apart destroys that value permanently. Unsigned costume pieces from the 1980s onward are almost always safe to repurpose.

I’ve handled thousands of pieces across two decades in manufacturing, and the rule I give people is simple: a maker’s mark stamped into the metal on the back of the pin — even a tiny oval or script signature — means someone should look at it before it gets glued to anything. Foil-backed, hand-set rhinestones (a reflective backing behind each stone, visible under a loupe) usually signal an older, more valuable piece. If you’re unsure what you’re holding, a community like PriceScope has collectors who can eyeball photos and flag anything worth an appraisal. For a deeper look at what separates a keeper from a craft-bin piece, see our guide on what to look for in vintage jewelry.

Turn the Brooch Into a Framed Piece of Wall Art

An old picture frame and a scrap of black felt is all you need. Pin the brooches directly to the felt backing before you seat it in the frame — this holds costume pieces (most are pot metal or brass with a thin rhodium or gold wash) without any adhesive that could damage the finish. Chalk paint the frame and rough up the edges with 120-grit sandpaper for a distressed, country-rustic finish that reads intentional rather than dated.

A straight, evenly spaced row of matching butterfly or floral brooches reads formal; scattering mismatched pieces at different heights reads collected-over-time. Keep the felt black or dark charcoal — light backgrounds wash out detail in oxidized silver-tone settings.

decorate your outfit

Can You Turn an Old Brooch Into a Necklace?

Yes, and it’s the single best return on effort of any idea here. Remove the pin mechanism with needle-nose pliers, file down the two solder points until smooth, then glue or solder on a bail. A brooch that’s been sitting in a drawer becomes a wearable pendant in under 10 minutes, no jewelry-making experience needed.

The pin mechanism on most vintage brooches is riveted or soldered to the back plate at two points — the hinge and the catch. A pair of flush cutters takes off the hinge and catch cleanly; a bit of 220-grit sanding smooths the stubs flush with the backing. From there, a self-adhesive bail or a dab of E6000 glue attaches to the top edge, and you thread it onto a chain. Barbara Michelle Jacobs walks through this exact conversion for larger statement brooches, and it’s the technique I recommend most because it doesn’t alter the front of the piece at all.

String Brooches Together Into a Statement Bracelet

Big, ornate brooches — the kind too heavy or dated to wear pinned to a lapel — work well strung together into a bib-style bracelet or collar necklace. Remove the pin backs the same way described above, sand the sharp points smooth, then link the pieces with metal jump rings (6-8mm, 18-gauge holds costume-weight pieces without bending) or thread them onto a thick grosgrain ribbon for a softer look. Three to five medium brooches is usually enough to fill a wrist without it feeling like armor.

Old earrings from the same era earn a second life here too — mismatched clip-ons blend in once everything is strung together. If you’ve got old charm bracelet pieces sitting alongside the brooches, our guide on what to do with old charm bracelets covers similar linking techniques.

Use that stunning brooch to make a brooch bracelet.

How Do You Decorate Plain Clothing With Brooches?

Pin two to three brooches from the same era or metal tone along one edge of a plain sweater or blazer lapel — never scatter more than that, or the look reads costume rather than styled. Sturdy, deep pinning through both layers of fabric keeps heavier vintage pieces from sagging or tearing knitwear.

The mistake most people make is mixing eras and finishes — a bright gold-tone 1980s pin next to a dulled Victorian mourning brooch looks like a garage sale, not an outfit. Match metal tone and general age, cluster them along one shoulder seam or lapel edge instead of spacing them evenly, and stop at three. If you like brooches as a styling category generally, we cover current pairings in are brooches in fashion right now.

Multi-Strand Bracelets With a Brooch Centerpiece

Smaller beaded or pearl bracelets link into one wide cuff when you use a brooch as the centerpiece. Lay three or four thin bracelets side by side, then attach both ends of each strand to the brooch’s pin catch (now repurposed as an anchor point) with jump rings. Pearls, glass beads, and cubic zirconia strands all work, and nothing needs to be cut or soldered — a pair of jewelry pliers and 10 minutes is all it takes.

Use that stunning brooch to make a brooch bracelet.

How Do You Turn a Brooch Into a Hairpiece?

Replace the pin’s clasp hardware with a metal hair comb using E6000 glue or a small amount of solder. This keeps the brooch from tugging or pulling hair the way a bare pin does, and it holds securely through a full day of wear, including wedding-length hours.

This is one of the most requested conversions I see, mostly around wedding season, because a brooch stands in beautifully for a veil comb without the cost of new bridal jewelry. Avoid resin or plastic-backed brooches for this — the glue bond to a comb needs a metal surface to hold long-term.

Frame Your Photos With Brooch Corners

Glue a brooch to each of the four corners of a plain photo frame using E6000 or a hot glue gun, and you get a decorative border that turns a basic frame into an heirloom-style piece. Antique or vintage-finish brooches read best here — the patina works as an intended framing accent rather than looking randomly stuck on. Two matching pairs, four total, is the right amount; more than that and the photo gets lost behind the hardware.

Use that stunning brooch to make a brooch bracelet.

Can You Make a Fridge Magnet From an Old Brooch?

Yes — remove the pin-back with needle-nose pliers, then glue a flat, high-strength magnet to the flattened back using E6000. It’s the fastest project on this list, done in under five minutes per piece with no tools beyond pliers and glue.

Broken-pin brooches — the ones where the catch snapped off years ago and they’ve been sitting in a drawer as junk — are the best candidates, since you’re removing hardware you’d otherwise have to work around. Milly’s Marvels has a good rundown of which antique finishes hold up best once converted this way. A cluster of five or six on a fridge makes a genuinely nice piece of everyday art out of pieces otherwise headed for a donation bin.

Brooch-Embellished Candle Holders and Curtain Tiebacks

Wrap a plain glass candle holder with color-coordinated ribbon, then hot-glue two or three brooches around the base — a fifteen-minute project that’s a good use for pieces with missing or bent pin-backs, since nothing needs to open or close. Match the stone color to your room’s palette rather than treating it as a random accent.

The same hardware works as curtain tiebacks: thread a sturdy brooch onto ribbon or cord, wrap it around gathered curtain fabric, and pin or hook it closed. Bigger, chunkier brooches hold shape better here than small, delicate pieces — the tieback needs structural weight to keep the curtain gathered through the day.

Are Old Brooches Worth Any Money?

Most costume brooches from department stores and catalogs are worth $5-$20 as-is, not enough to skip repurposing over. Signed designer pieces (Trifari, Weiss, Miriam Haskell, Chanel) or anything with real gemstones and gold or platinum settings can be worth $100 to several thousand dollars, and those are the only ones worth a professional appraisal before you cut into them.

The resale market for repurposed and as-is vintage brooches is active — browse any Etsy marketplace search for “vintage brooch” and you’ll see hundreds of listings. If your brooch feels unusually heavy for its size, or a clasp is marked “sterling” or “925,” set it aside and get it appraised — that’s real silver, and the stones may be genuine rather than glass. For more on how costume pieces get valued, see our breakdown of costume jewelry value.

Embellish a Tote Bag or Fabric Accessory

Five or six brooches affixed to a canvas tote — arranged vertically along one strap or clustered in one corner — turns a plain bag into a piece that looks intentionally designed rather than accessorized after the fact. Keep every brooch facing the same direction, right-side up relative to the bag, not scattered at random angles, or the effect reads sloppy instead of curated.

Canvas and heavier cotton totes hold pin weight better than lightweight nylon, which sags and tears around the pin holes over time. If your collection runs toward smaller brooches under an inch, our notes on how to wear a Chanel brooch cover placement principles that translate directly to bag styling.

The Bottom Line

Not every old brooch belongs in a craft project. Check for a maker’s mark and real gemstone weight first — that five-minute check is the difference between a $200 mistake and a genuinely great DIY piece. Everything else, though, is fair game: the pin mechanism that makes brooches hard to wear today is exactly what makes them easy to convert into pendants, magnets, hair combs, and home accents. Start with the pieces that have broken clasps or missing stones, nothing to lose there, before you move on to intact pieces you might still want to wear as-is. If brooches turn out to be more your style than you expected, browse our guide on whether brooches are back in fashion for ways to wear them the traditional way, too.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do you remove a pin back from a brooch without damaging it?

Use needle-nose pliers to gently bend and pull the hinge and catch away from the back plate — most are riveted or soldered at two small points. Work slowly and support the front of the brooch with your other hand so you don’t bend the face. Sand any leftover metal stubs flush with 220-grit sandpaper before adding new hardware like a bail or magnet.

Are vintage brooches from the 1950s and 1960s worth more than newer ones?

Generally yes, if they carry a maker’s mark from a recognized name like Trifari, Coro, or Weiss. Mid-century pieces used better-quality pot metal castings and hand-set rhinestones compared to most costume jewelry made after the 1990s, which tends to use cheaper stamped settings and glued stones.

What glue works best for brooch repurposing projects?

E6000 is the standard for jewelry crafts because it bonds metal, glass, and fabric, and it stays flexible instead of turning brittle. It needs 24-72 hours to fully cure, so let a project sit overnight before wearing or handling it. Avoid super glue for anything load-bearing since it’s brittle and cracks under repeated flexing.

Can costume jewelry brooches be melted down for scrap value?

Almost never worth it. Most costume brooches are pot metal, brass, or zinc alloy with a thin gold or rhodium plating measured in microns, and there isn’t enough precious metal to recover. Scrap value only applies to pieces marked sterling, 14k, or 18k, and even then, a jeweler needs to verify the marking before buying it as scrap.

How many brooches do you need for a wall art display?

Five to eight brooches fills a standard 8×10 or 11×14 frame without crowding. Fewer than five looks sparse against a felt background; more than ten in a small frame starts to compete for attention and the individual pieces get lost.

Hey! I finally find the Answer!