Simulated Morganite Vs. Real Morganite- Differences, Pros&Cons)

Hey! I finally find the Answer!

Morganite is the next best option if you want a unique and less traditional gem than diamonds, to add sparkle to your jewelry. These beautiful stones are an increasingly popular trend in jewelry today. Although they are cheaper than diamonds, they can be considerably costly when paired with precious metals like rose gold. There are therefore simulated morganite options for this looking a cheaper alternative.

The problem, however, is telling the difference between genuine and simulated morganite. Some jewelers may try to pass off the simulated stone as real, so, how do you avoid getting duped?

In this post, we are going to look in-depth at the differences between simulated and real morganite and which one is worth buying.

oh, do not forget to read more tips and topics here and here!


What Is Simulated Morganite?

simulated morganite vs. real morganite

Based on the term simulate, which means an imitation of the original, simulated morganite can be said to be a stone that mimics the real morganite. Although many people use the terms simulated and synthetic interchangeably, there is a difference between the two.

With synthetic morganite, this is a man-made gemstone that is created in the lab. This type of morganite has the same chemical composition as naturally occurring morganite. The only difference is that it is created in the lab. Simulated morganite on the other hand may be created in the lab but they are not the exact replicas of the real morganite. In as much as they may look exactly like real morganite in terms of color, they do not share the same composition.

It is similar to how cubic zirconia and white sapphire are simulations of diamonds. In the same way, simulated morganite shares the same sparkle and pink hue of a real morganite but is not made of the same substances. A good example could be colored glass.


The Pros And Cons Of Simulated Morganite.

In as much as simulated morganite is not the real deal, there are some upsides and downsides to using simulated morganite over the real gem. The following are some of the pros and cons of simulated morganite:

simulated morganite vs. real morganite


  • It is more affordable since it is usually half the price of real morganite.
  • It is readily available, unlike real morganite that tends to be rare.
  • Can come in a larger variety of colors outside of the subtle pink shades of real morganite.


  • It has less value than real morganite in terms of resell value.
  • It does not have the same quality and durability as real morganite.
  • It is too flawless and lacks the imperfections of real morganite that make it unique.


What Is Real Morganite?

Genuine morganite is a semi-precious pinkish stone that belongs to the beryl mineral family.

simulated morganite vs. real morganite

The gem is a close cousin to the likes of emerald and aquamarine and includes them in its composition. Morganite naturally occurs in subtle pink shades due to the presence of manganese in its composition.

The shades range from pink to orange-pinkish. It is very rare to find strong coloring in natural morganite unless the gem is large. It often has to undergo heat treatment to enhance the pink color. This is because the heat gets rid of the yellowish hue leaving a pure pink color.

In terms of durability, morganite is hard enough to survive daily wear. It’s however not strong enough to resist a strong impact like falling or hitting against a hard surface. As for value, morganites are considerably cheaper than diamonds.

Generally, they cost 10 times less than diamonds by weight. Their value however can vary by color whereby the medium-light to medium pink is considered more valuable. Smaller morganites with more intense colors are also considered more valuable than the bigger ones.  


The Pros And Cons Of Real Morganite.

As you know, everything has its ups and downs. The following are the pros and cons of using real morganite:

simulated morganite vs. real morganite


  • It is an inexpensive option for colored gemstones compared to diamonds.
  • It is durable and can survive daily wear.
  • It is rare and more unique compared to diamonds.
  • It pairs very well with rose gold given its pink hue.
  • It is suitable for most skin tones especially those with a fairer complexion.


  • It is less resistant to scratches compared to other gemstones.
  • It is still more costly than simulated morganite.
  • It is not as readily available as simulated morganite.
  • It is pink hue may clash with most metals outside of rose gold.


The Differences Between Simulated Morganite And Real Morganite.

simulated morganite vs. real morganite

Based on visual appearance it can be difficult to tell apart a real morganite from a stimulated one. This is especially true for those who don’t know about gemstones, more specifically morganite. That is why the best way to tell them apart is by having a professional look at them. Still, some differentiating factors between the two can help in telling them apart.

The main differentiating factor is the pricing. While real morganite is 10 times cheaper than diamond, it is still charged at approximately $300 per carat. If you were to buy the morganite for a significantly cheaper price than this, then the chance is that it is a simulated morganite. That is because simulated morganite tends to be almost half the price, hence the cheaper option.

Another differing factor would be the composition of the two. As we’ve already explained, simulated gems may mimic the appearance of the real gem but they do not share the same composition. So, to tell them apart you may want an expert to examine their respective compositions.

Other properties that may help you differentiate the two, would be things like durability and flawlessness. Simulated morganite is not as durable as the genuine one. It is also created in a lab and therefore almost flawless. Unlike genuine morganite, simulated morganite does not have the imperfections of a naturally occurring morganite that makes it so unique.


Simulated Morganite Vs. Real Morganite – Which One You Should Buy?

simulated morganite vs. real morganite

There is no clear-cut answer as to which one is worth buying over the other. As you have seen, each one has its disadvantages and advantages. So, it’s a matter of preference.

It could be possible that you fall in love with the appearance of a simulated morganite and not bother with whether it’s genuine or not.

Price is also a defining factor. If you are on a tight budget, then simulated morganite is the best option for you. But if you value quality and durability over price, then you might want to opt for the real morganite. Simulated morganites are also a better option when you are looking for a specific color, cut, or clarity.

That is because there is more control over the making process, compared to naturally occurring morganite. Some would even say that genuine morganite has a foggier clarity than simulated morganite. You just need to decide which one you prefer more.



Morganite is especially a popular trend in engagement rings and weddings sets for non-traditional brides. Most people love the stone for its gentle color.

Whether it is simulated and real morganite, both are equally as beautiful. So, there is no issue with opting for the simulated version if you want a cheaper option.

You should however be careful not to be conned by jewelers who try to pass of simulated morganites as the authentic ones.

Hey! I finally find the Answer!