Are Blue Nile Diamonds Still Good in 2024?(With Pros & Cons)

Hey! I finally find the Answer!

Are Blue Nile Diamonds Good? Can I buy one? As you know, there are different types/ sources of diamonds, and knowing the best place to buy certified and conflict-free diamonds is essential.

In this article, we’ll take a look at everything you need to know about Blue Nile diamonds, whether they are good or not, and what makes the brand good (or bad).


Everything you need to know about Blue Nile Diamonds

Founded in 1999, Blue Nile is a leading brand dealing in diamond engagement rings. Blue Nile’s founder, Mark Vadon’s search for the perfect engagement ring, led him to believe that diamonds were an essential commodity.

So, he took the time to learn all about this commodity them shop the best prices. With knowledge from, he learned pretty much everything he needed to know about this brand, and this led to the birth of Blue Nile.

Note that unlike other dealers in diamonds, Blue Nile’s business model involves listing diamonds on their site from diamond wholesalers and manufacturers directly.

This way, the site has a huge inventory and, most importantly, thin margins, and overall competitively priced, high-quality diamonds.


Are Blue Nile diamonds lab-grown?

With a philosophy that goes beyond diamonds that are just conflict-free, all the diamonds by the Blue Nile are from mines where the employees work in safe conditions, and they are paid fair wages.

But this brand doesn’t just offer natural, conflict-free diamonds, Blue Nile takes pride in the creation of lab-grown diamonds from recycles metals.

So, to answer your question, we’d say that only a percentage of Blue Nile diamonds are lab-grown.


Are Blue Nile diamonds good?

While Blue Nile diamonds lack in terms of setting variety and the diamonds listed don’t always appear as high-resolution photos, Blue Nile diamonds are generally good.

The company makes use of a diamond upgrade program, they offer price matching, and all diamonds bought from the site have a lifetime warranty, as well as insured and free priority shipping plans and returns.

Blue Nile offers a very large selection of diamonds online, all sourced from suppliers worldwide.

To ensure that their clients trust the diamonds sold, all pieces come with comprehensive grading reports, which means that you will always know exactly what you are buying.


Pros of Blue Nile diamonds

Among other reasons, Blue Nile offers outstanding pricing for diamonds, and they also have a monumental selection of diamonds compared to its competitors.

Here is a look at the winning features and characteristics of Blue Nile Diamonds.

1.Conflict-Free Diamonds.

Blue Nile sources all its diamonds from known and certified conflict-free areas.

They also source from manufacturers that only follow the Kimberly manufacturing Process, which means that the diamonds sourced undergo a comprehensive certification process.

Following the Kimberly Process also means that the diamonds have been certified as diamonds that aren’t from the conflict-zones of the world. It’s also worth noting that Blue Nile has been existence for about two decades now, and it’s got the support of 81 nations, including the United Nations mandate.

By taking all these steps, Blue Nile is doing all it possibly can to only source diamonds from the conflict-free zones.


2.Not commission-based.

Most other online sites that deal with diamonds operate on a commission-based system, which can be very annoying.

But this is not the case with Blue Nile, meaning that you wouldn’t have to worry about pressure tactics or the heavy and annoying sales pitches before you buy.

Blue Nile is also structured such that if you choose to buy their diamonds online, you wouldn’t have to deal with or have any human interactions.

Without the heavy-handed online sales tactics, Blue Nile is more attractive compared to some of its competitors.


3.Free, Insured Shipping.

The other winning feature of Blue Nile is that the company offers free, insured shipping for their diamonds via FedEx’s Priority Overnight.

Blue Nile further offers a free 30-day returns period, which means that you’d be able to return or exchange any diamond piece brought from the company within the initial 30 days of purchase.

Since shipping is free and the returns will be shipped free, and the diamonds are insured, you really won’t have much to worry about working with Blue Nile.


4.Complimentary Services – Cleaning and Inspection.

Like all other leading jewelry companies, Blue Nile offers complimentary inspection and cleaning services.

All you need to do is to ship the jewelry piece to Blue Nile, and the company will pay to ship it back.

You can also send it to them for cleaning, and they will go the extra mile to inspect the jewelry piece and see if there is any need for repairs.

In such cases, you’d have to pay for repairs, as well as the cost of having the jewelry shipped back.

5.Lifetime manufacturer’s warranty.

The other benefit that comes with shopping from Blue Nile is that the diamonds purchased from them come with a lifetime warranty from the manufacturer, meaning that the jewelry will be repaired or replaced if it’s determined that the piece had a manufacturing defect.


6.Upgrade program.

The other benefit of buying from Blue Nile is that the company has an upgrade program, and depending on the amount of money spent on the diamonds, you could trade it for a larger diamond, but only if the new diamond is double the price of the original diamond.


7.Price Match Guarantee.

The other reason why you might like Blue Nile is that they offer price match guarantees.

So, if you come across comparable diamonds on a different site at a lower price than what Blue Nile charges, you could ask for a price match by calling Blue Nile.

Just know that Blue Nile will first have to grade that diamond, and it has to pass GIA standards.

Cons of Blue Nile diamonds

  • First, Blue Nile doesn’t offer many setting options for diamonds.
  • The image resolution for Blue Nile isn’t the best, and not every one of Blue Nile’s diamonds gets that 360-degree treatment.



Blue Nile is one of the most reputable brands of diamonds, and if you are looking for a brand that sells certified and conflict-free diamonds affordably, Blue Nile would be a good place for you to start. Thanks for reading. For more fashion brand topics, please read here or visit our home for more.

Hey! I finally find the Answer!